Dorset Climate Action Network
  • Home
  • COP27
  • Donate
  • Newsletters
  • What Can I Do?
  • Campaigns
    • Dorset Deserves Better >
      • DDB 080622
    • Dorset Greener Open Homes
    • Dorchester Transport Action Group (DTAG)
    • Local Plan / CEES
    • Dorset Rivers and Beaches
    • No Oil
    • Great Big Dorset Hedge >
      • Sign up - Great Big Dorset Hedge
    • Highmoor Farm
    • Henry - Great Big Dorset Hedgehog
  • News
  • Contact
  • Local Groups
  • Teams
    • Advocacy Team
    • Energy Team
    • Land Use Team
    • Media & Comms Team
    • Questions Team
    • Transport Team
    • DCan Youth Group
  • Members


Current  News

Dorset Council Annual Meeting 12th May 2022

14/5/2022

0 Comments

 
Below is a summary of some parts of the contentious council meeting on 12th May where DorsetCAN asked a question about the Chair's refusal to allow a debate on a motion about energy security and fossil fuels.

You can see a video of the meeting here and a report by journalist Trevor Bevins on Planet Radio here.

Dorset CAN's summary:

There was a lively discussion with lots of noise outside from XR and a steel band while inside there was passion, insults, ineptitude, growling and some very decent speeches. Local democracy in action in all its tenuous glory.
 
The main debate related to the previous council meeting on 14th April and conflated three different issues together causing unnecessary confusion and providing plenty of wiggle room for the conservatives to dodge the main questions. The first issue was whether to condemn the actions of the two protestors. The second was whether Madame Chair (Val Pothecary) had made the right (democratic) decision to stop all debate and go straight to a vote and the third, the most important, was about why the energy security motion was passed even though it was in clear contradiction to the IPCC and DC’s own Climate and Ecological Emergency Strategy.
 
The first issue was the subject a tabled motion. The Lib Dems/Green immediately tabled an amendment which was more conciliatory and would have toned down the wording to “regret” for the actions of the two protestors - but this was rejected and the original motion passed.
 
The second issue, on whether Madame Chair had acted democratically was debated hard along with the third issue on the climate impacts of increasing fossil fuel extraction etc.  The second issue was the key point in our two questions. The conservatives did not like being told they were acting undemocratically and started barracking Giles Watts (who asked the question for DorsetCAN) - the barracking was led by the Councillors O’Leary and Lacey-Clarke - before the questions had even been asked. The reply from Val Pothecary was fairly predictable. First,s he admonished us for merely “noting” the actions of the protestors (rather than condemning them) and then went on to justify her actions as protecting the safety of the councillors.
 
It was a long and fairly brutal debate with excellent speeches by Caz Dennett, Cllr Belinda Bawden, Cllr Heatley and others from the Lib Dem and Green camps – with some reasonable speeches from a few conservatives, notably Ray Bryan. Sadly the debate was mainly on party pollitcial lines with some pretty gross political arse-licking at times. Luckily there were also some patient and thoughtful speeches by people who reminded us all that Climate issues are of major importance to us all, that we must all try to listen to the electorate (even when we don’t like what they say) and that historically direct action has its natural place in society when democracy is not working well (e.g. Suffragettes and Black Lives Matter)
 
It is unclear why the motion on energy security was put forward in the first place and why the conservatives were so keen to hold a vote immediately after the protest rather than delaying until later – which would have been much more “democratic”. Interestingly, it was admitted during the debate that immediately after the vote on 14th April, a letter had been sent to Greg Hands (Minister of State for Business, Energy and Clean Growth of the United Kingdom) saying that Dorset Council was completely supportive of the government’s Energy Strategy. It would be good to see the text of this letter to Greg Hands (there is no record of it on the Dorset Council web site).

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021

    Categories

    All
    Activism
    Air Pollution
    BCP
    BCP Council
    Beaminster
    Beavers
    Bees
    Biodiversity
    Blackmore Vale
    Bridleways
    Bridport
    Call To Action
    CEE Bill
    CEE Strategy
    Climate Emergency UK
    Coastal Erosion
    COP26
    Corfe Castle
    Cornwall
    CPRE
    Deposit And Return Scheme
    Devon
    Dorset Council
    Dorset Local Plan
    Dorset National Park
    Dorset Wildlife Trust
    Doughnut Economics
    ECHR
    ELMS
    Energy Efficiency
    Environment Agency
    European Union
    Farming
    Festivals
    Flooding
    Fossil Fuels
    Gert Dorset Hedge
    Great Big Green Week
    Growth
    Housing
    Incinerator
    Insects
    International
    IPCC
    Land Use Team
    Lewes
    Marnhull
    Meteorology
    National Grid
    Nature
    Oil Drilling
    Parish/Town Councils
    Pensions
    People's Assembly
    Pesticides
    Planet Purbeck
    Planning
    Plastics
    Polar Icecaps
    Portland
    Public Engagement
    Public Services
    Rivers
    Seas And Oceans
    Shaftesbury
    Solar Farms
    Stonehenge
    Stour Valley
    Tool
    Transport
    Trees
    UK Developments
    UK Politics
    United Nations
    Whales And Dolphins
    Wildfires
    Wimborne
    Wind Energy
    Youth
    Zero Carbon

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • COP27
  • Donate
  • Newsletters
  • What Can I Do?
  • Campaigns
    • Dorset Deserves Better >
      • DDB 080622
    • Dorset Greener Open Homes
    • Dorchester Transport Action Group (DTAG)
    • Local Plan / CEES
    • Dorset Rivers and Beaches
    • No Oil
    • Great Big Dorset Hedge >
      • Sign up - Great Big Dorset Hedge
    • Highmoor Farm
    • Henry - Great Big Dorset Hedgehog
  • News
  • Contact
  • Local Groups
  • Teams
    • Advocacy Team
    • Energy Team
    • Land Use Team
    • Media & Comms Team
    • Questions Team
    • Transport Team
    • DCan Youth Group
  • Members